5 Ways To Create Engaging and Interactive Instagram Stories

Are you creating Instagram Stories but you’re not seeing the results? Or you’re not sure which Instagram Stories to share to meet your business goals? That’s why in this blog post I’m going to teach you five ways to create engaging and interactive Instagram Stories. 

400 million people tune into Instagram Stories every day, so if you’re looking to gain more followers and increase your engagement now is the time!

Why Interactive Instagram Stories Are Important 

Building a successful strategy for Instagram Stories doesn’t have to be complex or time-consuming. Instead, you want to map out a strategy that builds upon the engagement that you’re seeing in your Instagram feed. Here are three other benefits of having people physically engage with your Instagram Stories:

#1 Helps You Work With (Not Against) The Algorithm

Just like the Instagram feed algorithm, Instagram Stories tries to connect people with the content they’re most interested in. That means the more people engage with your Stories, the more likely they are to see your content in the future. What do I mean by engagement? I mean people are physically taking their finger and interacting with your Instagram Story, they’re not just watching with their eyes.

#2 People Are More Likely to Watch Your Whole Instagram Story

Having people watch your Instagram Stories from beginning to end is no easy feat. In other words, it’s important that you keep an eye on your viewer retention. By adding more engaging elements into your Instagram Stories, something we’ll dive into shortly, you’re encouraging people to do more than just passively tap through your Instagram Stories.

#3 Your Followers Will Feel Connected to You Much Faster

I’ve always said that it’s not about the number of followers you have, but the relationships you build. Instagram Stories is your opportunity to turn your followers into loyal customers. By taking the time to show you’re interested in cultivating meaningful relationships, people will feel more compelled to put in the effort to engage with you.

Here are the top five ways to make your Instagram Stories more engaging.

#1 Ask A Question

Sometimes it’s not just about the question you ask in Instagram Stories, but how you ask it. That’s why I love to mix it up by using Instagram’s variation of its polling sticker: the sliding scale.

Adding a sliding scale poll is easy, here’s how you do it:

–       Upload a photo just like you would for an Instagram Story, then click on the stickers tab at the top of the screen

–       Click on the sliding scale sticker

–        Type your question and pick an emoji that fits the tone of your question

This Instagram sticker allows you to ask people “how” instead of just a simple yes or no question. For example, you could ask people how much they love your latest product or how much they’re looking forward to your brand’s upcoming launch. The emoji will animate as they drag it up and down the scale, and you can even see how individuals answered. Even after you get your final poll results, don’t forget to leverage this engagement too. You can either create a Stories clip with your reaction to the poll or share the poll results in a screenshot.

#2 Ask People To Send An Instagram Direct Message For A Link

If you’ve read any of my past blog posts about Instagram direct message, then you know that the magic goes down in the Instagram Direct Message. This is your chance to have one-on-one conversations and show people that there’s a real person behind your brand.

Your followers will love that you took the time to respond, and you get to cultivate strong customer relationships, it’s a win-win. Sometimes it doesn’t even have to be directly related to your business … you shouldn’t be selling 24/7 anyway. Often, I’ll highlight a product, like this mat, that I love in my Stories and encourage my followers to reach out for the link to buy. It’s a customer connection that feels genuine and is really easy to do.

#3 Add A Clickable Instagram Sticker

One of the biggest opportunities in Instagram Stories is the chance to connect with other people in a hashtag hub or in your community. When you use the hashtag and/or location sticker not only will your Stories be seen by your followers, but now you have an opportunity to be seen by anyone. If enough people engage with your Instagram Stories, you might even end up on the Explore page.

You can also tag people in your Stories. It’s a small gesture, but it makes it easier for them to repost your Stories clip on their account and gives them a shout out… which everyone loves!

#4 Promote your own content

When Instagram rolled out the ability to add posts to your Instagram Stories, it was a big deal. It goes without saying that the ability to send your followers to your specific posts from your Story is really useful. Whether it’s your latest blog post or a new product, this is your chance to “tease” your feed content. Just make sure when you’re adding text to your Stories clip that you tell them why they should tap into check out that post.

Want to create more FOMO? Take a screenshot of the post and cover part of it with a fun Gif. You can also use Stories to send people to the link in your bio or share your IGTV video.

Ninja Tip: If you’re going to drive people from your Stories to your feed, you want to tell them the value in tapping through.

But you also want to track how many people are going from your Stories to your feed. That’s why I recommend using a dedicated hashtag, something that resonates like a keyword or phrase, that you encourage people to use when they comment on your post. For example, my dedicated hashtag is #SueBStories.

#5 Use An Instagram Question Sticker to Get Feedback

Instead of sending out a lengthy survey that no one is likely to respond to, give people a more instant, fun way to share their opinions by using Instagram question stickers. Just like the sliding scale, you want to think about questions that are actually worth asking.

This is your opportunity to understand your followers’ goals, preferences and, possibly, help you to brainstorm more Instagram content for the future. The responses to your questions will help you to create more content that grabs the attention of your followers and encourages them to tap through while actively engaging with your Instagram Story.  

Strategies to Make Instagram Stories Work Better for Your Business  


If you still feel like you don’t have time to create Instagram Stories for your business, be sure to check out my youtube video. It’s all about one of my favorite Instagram tools, Planoly, and how it can help you improve your efficiency without sacrificing content quality.